August 14, 2005
4 Comments

Bret Easton Ellis, "Lunar Park"

lunarp.gifHere's the biggest problem with Bret Easton Ellis: You can't tell if, to paraphrase Ann Magnuson, he's being ironic or sarcastic or postmodern. His career peaked with American Psycho, his worst book. And despite the media blitz, and the inexplicable handjob reviews from odd places, it's safe to say that Lunar Park is not going to help him reclaim that notoriety.

His rise to fame--during which he defined that special 80s zeitgeist--is the stuff of legend, and you can't tell me that when you read Less Than Zero or Rules of Attraction (because you most certainly did) in college that you didn't feel a twinge of some sort of jealousy...creative, social, or otherwise.

When American Psycho was released, Ellis graduated from bete noir to criminally insane douchebag. But, y'know, there's no such thing as bad publicity. Nothing he's written since then has attracted the same amount of notoriety or commercial success.

And that's where Lunar Park begins, with actual author Bret Easton Ellis giving up his debauched NYC partyboy lifestyle for comfortable suburban living. Or is it a Fake Bret Easton Ellis (FBEE), a fictional one whose life just coincidentally parallels that of the Real Bret Easton Ellis(RBEE)? The RBEE insists that LP is a work of fiction, but FBEE, the narrator, tells us that every word of it is true. (Ironic? Sarcastic? Postmodern?) I won't be ruining the book for you by mentioning that it aspires to be a horror story--obvious evidence that it's fiction, right?--but is FBEE the RBEE's homunculus or what? Because FBEE is both totally unsympathetic and also perversely, narcissistically proud of his shortcomings, just like RBEE.

FBEE is a man who wants to leave behind his drug-addled, star-fucking past, so he settles down in ur-Westchester County with Jayne Dennis, the big movie star with whom he had a child years earlier, in a posh residence on Elsinore Lane. (Pay attention, folks, because THAT, my friends, is called FORESHADOWING.) Forget the niggling drug addiction and the antisocial behavior of yore: The one thing that FBEE is unable to escape is the memory of his dead father. Why not? Because his father is sending him blank emails from beyond the grave! (Coincidentally, my mother also does this, but she's alive.) ELSINORE LANE! Get it?

Other weird things begin to happen. FBEE is being stalked by someone who resembles Patrick Bateman, protagonist of AP. Oh, and there's something leaving slime trails and peeling paint all around his house. The house which, inexplicably, is slowly turning into his childhood home. And, ah, also, his stepdaughter's doll is trying to kill him. Worst of all: This pretty grad student won't fuck him.

While all this paranormal activity is taking place, there are other earthly issues too. There's his substance abuse problem, his disintegrating marriage, and his estranged relationship with his 'tween son. It is hard to kick against the pricks, true, but by the time I got halfway through the story I was beginning to think it really should've been called Are You There God? It's Me Bret Easton Ellis. Because his struggles are more in the realm of adolescent angst than any slings and arrows Hamlet suffered.

Things happen: the stalking continues, the sliming/haunting worsens, area boys start disappearing, his wife threatens to leave him, and then someone starts murdering folks in the same style as Patrick Bateman. Ain't that some shit? FBEE comes to the startling, nonsensical conclusion that all of these problems are the result of the characters he's created in his stories. It's convoluted, but to keep this review short(er), I'll share the stupidest reason: All those blank emails he's been receiving from his dad? They're not blank; they have mpeg attachments! Of the night his father died! How his AOL account hadn't reached its storage capacity is beyond me, as is the fact that he hadn't noticed the attachments for over a year--but then again, it's hard to expect much from an AOL user to begin with.

In short order, the appearances of the apparition--a squat, snarling mouth-creature covered with hair--get so bad that he calls in Ghostbusters; the sexy grad student gets chopped into pieces, and everyone thinks that FBEE is going off the rails on a crazy train.

It's not difficult to tell a scary story--my brief stint in the Brownies taught me this--yet somehow RBEE fails miserably. Message to Bret: Psycho killer with hook for hand? Scary. Possessed child's doll and oversized Tribble? Not so much.

To complicate matters further, a third personality--The Writer--shows up to meta-narrate about three-quarters of the way through. So we've got RBEE, FBEE, and The Writer jockeying for who's the prettiest girl at the dance, and yet they're all so damned unlikeable that it's hard to really give a shit about any of them.

I'd love to know if Janet Maslin and I read the same novel, because while she was rhapsodizing, I was beginning to wish that Goatboy had descended onto the "Camden" campus* and gobbled up RBEE when he was an undergrad. A.O. Scott had a less charitable review, describing LP as "the first draft of an A.M. Homes novel." (Fuck you too, pal.) My conclusion? After a reading sixteen chapters wherein FBEE is chased around his McMansion by the hairy mouth creature, I was silently chanting GET HIM! EAT HIM!

*The seven of you reading this who also attended "Camden" and will get this. The other five of you reading this will just have to wonder.

Posted by Dana at 11:00 PM

Comments

Your "handjob review" link to the NYT has an extra line break in the link, so the link doesn't work. Feel free to delete this part of the comment.

I've never muched like Brett Easton Ellis, but I enjoyed your review. Probably more than I would like the book if I read it.

Posted by: Jesse at August 18, 2005 02:16 AM

Ah, whoops. Thanks on both counts, Jesse.

Posted by: dana at August 18, 2005 09:15 AM

So, you're saying: "Less Than Zero?"

The author appearing in his own novel goes back to Cervantes.

To quote from my web domain:
Ultimate Science Fiction Web Guide: Authors: C

Miguel de Saavedra Cervantes (1547-1616): "Don Quixote of La Mancha" was published in two volumes, 1605 and 1615. Your humble webmaster's mother learned to read Spanish primarily to read this great masterpiece of world literature.

An elderly country gentleman of La Mancha reads so many chivalric romances that he becomes insane, believes them to be true, and goes forth into the world as a knight-errant to right wrongs and defend the oppressed. Today one might read this as a warning to obsessed science fiction fans to, in the words of a famous William Shatner skit on Saturday Night Live "Get a Life!"

Since knight errants cannot do their thing without a lady-love, he chooses a local peasant girl he knew and dubs her Dulcinea. After his first sortie, wherein he's knighted, he convinces a good-natured but ignorant middle-aged local to be his sidekick, or esquire. Off they go,
through one adventure after another, which Don Quixote sees in delsional forms: a windmill as a giant, inns as castles, galley slaves as oppressed gentlemen. His buddy Sancho Panza sees things as they are, but both suffer terribly, returning home depressed and damaged.

A pseudo-Quixote novel was published in the next decade, and this goaded Miguel de Cervantes to write his own genuine sequel, which is even
better than the first volume. Wonderful chapters cover his dream in the cave of Montesinos, the puppet shows of Maese Pedro, adventures at the
Duke's castle, scenes with Robin Hood Guianrt, and the final defeat. When Quixote dies, Sancho Panza has become a beloved figure himself, so that the reader can hardly stand to leave the world of Quixote, which may have started as a satire on the fantasy genre of the day, but grew into a panoramic masterpiece of 17th century Spanish life. The mere entertainment became what many consider the first modern novel, which set a
standard for self-aware fantasy (at one point Quixote encounters a character pretending to be Quixote) which endures in the best work of today.

Posted by: Jonathan Vos Post at August 18, 2005 12:32 PM

How his AOL account hadn't reached its storage capacity is beyond me, as is the fact that he hadn't noticed the attachments for over a year--but then again, it's hard to expect much from an AOL user to begin with.

Pretty much hits the nail on the head. Of course if a ghost of an Overpriviliged Dead White Male is going to haunt an e-mail account, it would have to be AOL.

And wondering where Camden is. I went to school in Illium, myself.

Posted by: Jimcat Kasprzak at August 19, 2005 12:20 PM